This research examines managers’, employees’ and caregivers’ perceptions of the magnitude of the service failure in a context of non-profit organizations catering to people with mental disabilities. Building upon the social exchange, equity and prospect theory, we hypothesize that the gaps in the magnitude of the service failure play a moderating role on the negative effects of caregiver dissatisfaction and their desire for revenge and negative WOM behaviour. A group of 118 managers, 937 contact employees and 876 caregivers were surveyed. Hierarchical regression analyses support our hypotheses. Theoretical and managerial implications of the results are discussed.